If this is not properly formatted for your email, come to read at www.tomvmorris.com/blog. This is the sort of thing we do at our great Wisdom Weekend Retreats.
A good friend alerted me to an interesting and even beautifully written substack. The tagline of this post is:
<<Calmness is not the absence of emotion. It’s the result of understanding it.>>
You may have noticed recently that a lot of bestselling authors and influencers like to post insight nuggets of the form “X is not Y, it’s Z.” – For example, “Leadership isn’t about power, it’s about people.” I made that up just to illustrate, and it’s not bad, if I say so myself. But many memes of this form are misleading, even this one, because leadership is about both power and people. Good leaders use their power well, and give power to others, and those others tend to be people. But enough about my own meme.
This post I’m forwarding to you starts strong:<<There’s a certain kind of person who doesn’t raise their voice even when the world seems to be falling apart. They don’t argue. They don’t panic. They don’t rush to prove themselves right. They just breathe. And while everyone else is trying to make sense of the chaos, they quietly watch. Like someone who’s already been through this storm before. You’ve probably met someone like that. The kind of person who feels like silence itself has wrapped around them. No matter what happens, they remain composed, steady, grounded, untouchable. And if you’ve ever wondered why some people can stay so calm while others fall apart, the answer is far deeper than you might think. Calmness, real calmness, isn’t the absence of emotion. It’s what happens when emotion meets understanding. It’s not that these people don’t feel. They do. They just don’t react in the same way anymore.>>
First, note the claim “Calmness isn’t the absence of emotion.” But yeah, it is in part the absence of violent emotions like rage or giddy exultation. When others are on the emotional roller coaster, it’s not that the calm person feels no emotions, but the right ones in the right ways and to the right degree. So, it’s not the absence of all emotions but of some. And already we’ve corrected a misleading implication of how the author wrote.
Then, later after explaining how the rest of us are often enslaved to our amygdala, the fight or flight part of the brain, the author explains that for calm people:
<<Their prefrontal cortex, the rational thinking part of the brain, learns to step in before the emotion takes over. In other words, calm people have trained their minds to pause between feeling and reacting. That pause is their superpower. It’s why in an argument, they can hear something hurtful and not immediately strike back. It’s why they can sit in uncertainty without needing to fill the silence. It’s why when the world is loud, they can still hear themselves think.The pause between feeling and reacting is where wisdom lives.>>
Again I have to be a philosopher, which means in part a careful thinker. A brain surgeon can't just cut in roughly the right place. That pause between feeling and reacting is ONE OF THE PLACES wisdom operates, but not the only location for its work. When an event happens, there is a logical gap between that happening and our perception of it, then another gap between perception and interpretation, then another between interpretation and emotion, then another between emotion and the formation or strengthening of attitude and the launch of action. Wisdom lives in all these gaps.
The wise person doesn’t just take a breath to pause and prevent an otherwise unwise reaction. The wise person perceives, judges and reacts wisely in all ways. She doesn’t depend on one pause, toward the end of the sequence, where a foolish momentum may already be strong, but is wise throughout it all.Where then does wisdom dwell? In the heart and mind, throughout the whole person, in the soul, and it shows its light and does its work in every gap from event to action. Don’t let anyone, however great their other insights and keen their writing, tell you otherwise.
I share the whole substack because it does contain great reminders.
https://thethinkinganimal.substack.com/p/the-psychology-of-people-who-are-b85s